iPhone Life magazine

Smart Cover = Dumb Case?

In addition to the iPad 2, Apple's Smart Cover has been widely anticipated.  There is a lot to like about this accessory.  As the Smart Cover is opened, the iPad wakes up... and goes to sleep as the Smart Cover closes.  The Smart Cover peels back to form a stand, either for watching movies or typing.  And most significantly, it attaches via magnets... check out the tear-down from iFixit.  But this may be the iPad's version of AntennaGate.

Smart Covers tear down by iFixit

First, don't worry.  Magnets are not going to effect the internal solid state circuitry of the iPad.  True, if held close enough, magnets can cause problems for hotel keys, credit cards and magnetic-based media like hard drives.  But I don't anticipate that becoming a real problem.  The bigger issue is people will treat their Smart Covered iPad as if the two pieces were one.  Instead of fully supporting the iPad, users might be supporting the cover.  Imagine holding the iPad, with a Smart Cover open, like a book.  As you let go with your right hand, to touch the screen, the iPad is now supported only by the magnets.  They're strong but would you want to bet your iPad on how strong?

iPad 2 Smart Cover

It's not just a theory.  At least one unfortunate owner cracked his brand new iPad 2 within 48 hours, because his daughter pulled it off the coffee table by grabbing the Smart Cover.

I'm hoping that case manufacturers will pick up the ball and develop even better cases that provide full protection, make the iPad 2 easy to grip, and leverage the smart features (fold-to-stand, magnets, instant on/off) of Apple's Smart Covers.  But until then, keep a good grip on your iPad!

Email icon
Want more? Get our weekly newsletter:
Todd Bernhard's picture

Todd Bernhard is founder of No Tie Software, an app developer specializing in Ringtones and Sound FX including AutoRingtone.

An iPhone is almost always attached to his hip, but over the years, Mr. Bernhard has owned an Apple Newton, a Motorola Marco, an HP 95LX, a Compaq iPaq, a Palm Treo, and a Nokia e62.

In addition to writing for iPhone Life, Mr. Bernhard has written for iPhone Life’s sister publications (PocketPC Magazine and The HP Palmtop Paper).

Old Comments

Cover is Not a case!

I'm really suprised that Apple thinks everyone wants a cover and not a case to protect this expensive little jewel. I don't really care for the feel of raw aluminum nor do I like to see my pad get all scratched up. The smarts are OK but I don't think I'm the only one who actually liked the original full case, it felt good and safe to hold. No covers for me... and no black urethane really? only the black leather for $70 really??

Lastly regarding smart power, I learned from phones with this feature that it sometimes causes more trouble that it helps as other magnets or case shifting can power up or down the pad when not expected, but it can be turned off so it's not a big issue.

This is crap

I love apple products, but this is crap.
Its way over priced and not a case at all.
I have read several stories of people grabbing the cover and dropping their new iPad.
Bad design, should have had a grove on the back of the iPad to "Lock" it into.

A waste of money and possibly a waste of an iPad.

Run, leave it behind.

Don't blame the cover

Note to all! It is a cover, not a case. Don't blame a screwdriver for not being a good hammer. The new cover does a great job at what it is designed to do. If it does not meet your needs, buy something different.

IPad Cover

Listen to those spoiled babies. It's a COVER! Go out and buy a case if you want, don't blame Apple for being innovative.

Don't blame the cover!!

The price point for this smart cover is correct. It is the inexperienced tablet user who is the problem. It's a cover not a case, and if you grab ANY product by it's cover, i.e. a toaster it will fall to the floor, just like your iPad will, if you do NOT have a firm grip!

Apple did a FANTASTIC job bringing this COOL FUN product to life and you just beat it up because the cover comes off when you grab it, as it should in my humble opinion!!

Be Well!!